This page unintentionally left blank

You have balls to call yourself
a “writer” you fucking loser

In Reasons on 9 March, 2009

I didn’t let on to any­one that I like to write for twenty-eight and a half years, give or take a few agon­isingly illit­er­ate ones towards the very begin­ning. I didn’t think I was good enough (still don’t) to even sug­gest such a stretch. And yet I wrote. I always wrote. I didn’t save it, I didn’t sub­mit it any­where, I didn’t show it to friends, but if I wasn’t quietly self-destructing through abuse of hal­lu­cino­gens and bad rela­tion­ships, I wrote.

To over­sim­plify in the extreme, there are three kinds of writers (and mul­tiple com­bin­a­tions thereof):

  • Those who think they can write because they’re lit­er­ate (not writers)
  • Those who just write (writers)
  • Those who write, but require external val­id­a­tion to own it (writers or, more hope­fully and pre­cisely, pub­lished authors)

To write you have to insu­late your­self. You can’t read bull­shit opin­ion pieces like this and expect them to val­id­ate your feel­ings on the mat­ter. You have to ignore every­one: friends, lov­ers or oth­er­wise. You have to be insu­lar, but at the same time you can’t afford to dis­con­nect from the world of exper­i­ence — the mad­ness and suf­fer­ing around you — lest your writ­ing turn into a nar­ciss­istic blood­bath (just see my blog). So maybe you cre­ate fil­ters. This does not advance my think­ing, that does. This suits me, this can fuck off.

Judge­ment of worth is a tricky bitch, espe­cially the poor judge­ment you heap on your­self and your out­put without remorse. When you’re high, you think I’m bril­liant, the next [favour­ite fam­ous author]. When you’re low, your best work seems trivial and mundane at best. Who are you to dis­pense justice based on your flighty moods?

Writers are ordin­ary people who write because they must. Because not much of any­thing would make any sense oth­er­wise. The form their writ­ing takes extern­ally means little. Whether it is stashed away under the bed, in a des­ol­ate corner online, or a best-selling paper­back. Who cares? As long as someone reads it and even if no one reads it.

This feels obvi­ous, and yet if someone out­side of you — an agent, a pub­lisher, a lit­er­ary journal — doesn’t val­id­ate your writer­li­ness (it’s a word now, bitch), can you in good con­science call your­self a writer?

Why the fuck not?

If you have the scars to back it up when someone calls it in to ques­tion (and oh, they will) why the fuck not?

I’m a writer because I think and feel in words, because I’m not wholly human unless those fuck­ers are gush­ing from my fin­ger­tips or burn­ing my ret­ina. Because the time spent on other activ­it­ies seems an irre­con­cil­able waste that makes you want to poke your eye out with the nearest sharpened num­ber 2 (or HB to you Brits). Because my eyes and ears and hands, my body parts exist to write. A touch dra­matic per­haps, but you get me.

But mostly it’s because I fuck­ing say so and because, luck­ily, I live in a world where basic needs are fore­gone con­clu­sions and the pur­suit of such things as writ­ing and call­ing your­self a writer becomes possible.

The race for cash or an exist­ence free from work­aday stresses so you can con­cen­trate on writ­ing is laud­able (argu­ably) but ulti­mately sec­ond­ary. There’s pen and paper every­where and if you want to write you just do. You spit on the wall, on your hand, on yel­low post-it notes, laptops, in book mar­gins, on can­vas, on your fore­head, your stu­pid iPhone, pub­lic toi­let doors, in trains, on the soft, sweet bel­lies of the people you’re fuck­ing and their bedsheets.

And well, if you want to pub­lish my self-indulgent novel and sell me a few hun­dred cop­ies and still that’s the proof you need, then pretty for you. But you don’t make me what I am. I don’t even make me what I am.

I’m a writer and this is what I wrote. No more or less mean­ing­less or worth­while than all the shit you do day to day to make your own ordin­ary exist­ence feel less fright­en­ing and lonely.

Ani Smith. Editor of PIFFLE. Writer of Down In Me and Fuguestate. Fuck-up extraordinaire.

  1. Amen sis­ter.
    I’ve been writ­ing since I was a kid.
    I have note­books of shit from dec­ades back.
    I’ve been writ­ing on the inter­net even when nobody was read­ing it.
    I just have to.

  2. Very noble. I mean that sin­cerely, and in admir­a­tion. I too have writ­ten for a while but it’s only recently that I’ve stopped wor­ry­ing about validation.

  3. writ­ing chooses you

  4. See, there’s the mani­festo for this site — and more import­antly, what should be the mani­festo for any­one who writes — put most pith­ily: “We are writers because we fuck­ing say so”.

    Exactly. There is too much shit talked about ‘being a writer’. What ought to be talked about is the con­vic­tion, the need, to just do it. To just write. End of.

  5. Cheers, all. This was inter­est­ing. I’m not used to express­ing a one-sided opin­ion so out and out. I can think of a mil­lion reas­ons I’m wrong up there at the same time know­ing I’m not. Am I just wishy-washy? I don’t know.

  6. Oh P.S. Gor­don: I didn’t say I don’t worry about validation. :)

  7. the sweet bel­lies of people you’ve been fucking…

    ahhh

  8. “I’m a writer because I think and feel in words” — cuts to the chase, don’t it?

  9. i really liked this when i first read it. how­ever, my favour­ite bit of all may be:

    ‘I would love it if you, in a wholly caring way, went there and stomped the argu­ment full of holes and then laughed mani­ac­ally and maybe slapped it in the face medium hard and called it daddy’s little whore for a bit.’

  10. I agree that what makes someone a writer has very little to do with being pub­lished or val­id­ated or even appre­ci­ated. Some writers like to throw around Bukowski’s quote: “There is only one final judge of writ­ing and that is the writer.” I agree with Hank. But he did not mean that everything we type isn’t judged or should not be judged. It should be and is. And some­times we should listen. I’m cool with that. I think what Hank was say­ing is that you can’t change for other people, be true to your­self and all that shit. That’s all. Maybe there is some amaz­ing writer out there who types away day after day after day and has a dozen nov­els stuffed in a drawer that would blow our fuck­ing minds but we’ll never get to read it because this per­son is a selfish prick. That’s pos­sible. But what an asshole. We write for ourselves, abso­lutely, and that alone makes us writers. But we also write to be read, to share our twis­ted dreams with oth­ers, and to provide chub slaps to all who request them, Ani.

    Niiiiiiiiice

  11. well said and i never throw around bukowski quotes never

  12. Otto: Ooooh, thank you for the slap lovin’. May I have another? ;)

    That’s exactly what I was think­ing when I said ‘who are you to dis­pense justice based on your mood’ — I should have gone deeper into that, but didn’t: while it’s true that the ulti­mate judge is the writer, that judge­ment shouldn’t stand in the way of mak­ing the writ­ing avail­able (where pos­sible) and let­ting the reader (again where pos­sible) judge for him­self (but not for the writer). Luck­ily for us this is pos­sible and rel­at­ively easy right now.

  13. this is really good

  14. I like your point about the writer who calls him­self a writer so he can feel good about him­self, seek­ing to jus­tify his con­sump­tion of oxy­gen. I think that you might be that writer.

  15. I’m way late to the party but needed to say,

    Fuck yes.

All comments welcome, but please try to keep them on topic and relevant.